# Value Chain Position Profit

- Canonical ID: `profit-model-value-chain-position`

## Business pattern
Control an indispensable bottleneck or gatekeeping position in a value chain

## Profit mechanism
Dependence on a scarce passage point shifts bargaining power and value capture toward controller.

## Required discriminator
Value Chain Position vs Switchboard: indispensable chain bottleneck vs matchmaker Select by mechanism, not vocabulary similarity.

## Distinguishing questions
- Value Chain Position vs Switchboard: indispensable chain bottleneck vs matchmaker
- vs Standard: controlling required passage vs protocol adoption.

## Relevant failure modes to check
These are optional failure lenses, not assumptions about fit or failure. Apply a category only when supported by user evidence.

Categories: Position / Control Failure, Monetization Failure.

Failure characteristics to consider only when observed: absent, weak, delayed, reversed, saturated, volatile, too costly, blocked, displaced, decayed.

## Supporting evidence pattern
Mechanism to test: Dependence on a scarce passage point shifts bargaining power and value capture toward controller.

Positive signals: mandatory infrastructure, exclusive channel/input, toll/access fees, buyer/supplier dependence

Required causal link: Connect the distinctive structure to realized contribution, value capture, cost, control, scale, temporal advantage, deployed stock, or distribution; distinguish reported fact from inference.

Typically private evidence: share of value captured at bottleneck and contract terms; dependency/substitution/bypass rates; investment, compliance and continuity cost of controlling the passage point

Public limit: partial and claim-level; public evidence may establish offer structure but rarely unit economics

## Insufficient evidence
being one SaaS tool in workflow integration count alone A product feature, market position, growth claim, or mechanism label without an observed link to economic effect. Public silence or unavailable company economics; mark unknown/private rather than contradictory.

## Falsifier and no-fit boundary
credible evidence that the proposed profit mechanism is absent or economically immaterial evidence that apparent signal is only a feature/marketing statement and does not alter capture, cost, control, or distribution No fit when the required structural mechanism or its economically relevant causal path is absent, immaterial, contradicted, or not needed to explain the user’s issue.

Do not assign from name, feature, industry, size, or surface resemblance. If the issue is explained by routine execution, accounting/calculation, cash timing, a one-off discount negotiation, or another problem without this structural mechanism, use no-fit or route appropriately.

## Confusable alternatives
`profit-model-switchboard`, `profit-model-de-facto-standard`

Ask only the contrastive question that separates this mechanism from the strongest observed alternative. Missing/private evidence remains unknown.
