# HVAC Business Diagnosis — Takeaway

Nov 21, 2026 · @Akinobu Fukuzaki

[PDN Diagnosis] This is a working summary, dated 21 November 2026, of a diagnosis of a residential HVAC service company in suburban Houston. It is at the hypothesis stage: the facts below are the owner's own figures, but the explanations are not yet verified and the checks at the end are what will confirm or refute them.

## The business issue

Installations, the company's highest-value work, have fallen about 29% in three years while summers stay full and cash feels tighter. Several causes may be acting at once, and which one dominates decides whether the fix is mainly about sales, pricing or cash timing.

## Confirmed facts

All figures are the owner's, for last year unless noted. Shares and changes marked "calculated" are simple arithmetic on those figures.

| Revenue stream | Last year | Share (calculated) | Three years ago |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Repairs | about $584,000 | 46% | not known |
| New installations | about $400,000 | 31% | about $560,000 |
| Maintenance agreements | about $296,000 | 23% | not known |
| **Total** | **about $1.28 million** |  | not known |

- **Installations:** down about $160,000, or about 29%, over three years (calculated).
- **Agreements:** about 1,080 active at about $275 a year. Cancellations run about 3% a year and the count is flat, which implies roughly 30 new sign-ups a year (calculated).
- **Bids:** the owner writes all estimates and is losing more of them to national chains advertising low prices.
- **Owner's time:** age 58, about 55 hours a week, covering estimates and some field work.
- **Team:** 3 field technicians at $32–38 an hour plus summer overtime; 1 part-time office person (20 hours a week) for billing and scheduling.
- **Fixed costs:** shop and warehouse rent of $4,200 a month; 4 trucks.
- **Seasons:** peaks in June–August (cooling) and December–January (heating); slow in March–April and October.
- **Costs:** refrigerant, parts and labor prices are rising.
- **Selling agreements:** whether a technician offers one on a repair visit is up to each technician.
- **Never measured:** agreement attach rate, add-on sales to agreement customers, profit per agreement, revenue per technician, and lost quotes by customer type.

## Still a guess

None of these is confirmed. Each is a possible explanation that fits the facts so far.

1. **Busy is not the same as profitable.** As installations shrink, more of the year's work is repairs, which usually bring in less per crew-hour. Phones stay full while each hour earns less.
2. **The agreement base may not be producing replacement jobs.** About 1,080 member homes should be the best source of new systems. If members are also getting quotes from chains when their system fails, the company loses the most valuable moment in a relationship it built.
3. **Some losses may be about speed, not price.** Every estimate depends on the owner, whose busiest field weeks are also the busiest quoting weeks. A chain that quotes the same day can win before a competitive quote goes out.
4. **The agreement base isn't growing.** Few cancellations suggest customers value the plan. Few new sign-ups, left to each technician, point to how agreements are offered.
5. **Cash may be tight for up to four reasons at once:**
   1. less installation revenue
   2. repair rates and the agreement price may have fallen behind rising costs
   3. rent, trucks and technicians continue through three slow periods
   4. when agreement money comes in compared with when bills are due

There is also a longer-term point: installation sales run entirely through one person working about 55 hours a week. That limits growth and is a risk if the owner ever wants to step back.

## Important unknowns

| Question to verify | Evidence that would settle it | Which guess it tests |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Are lost installation quotes mostly agreement members or new leads? | Last 12 months of estimates, each marked member / new lead and won / lost | 2 |
| Are quotes lost because they go out too slowly? | Days from first call to quote sent, on the same estimates | 3 |
| Have repair rates and the $275 agreement price kept up with costs? | Invoices for 2–3 common repairs and an agreement renewal from about three years ago vs. today, set against supplier invoices for the same parts | 5.2 |
| Do agreement customers pay yearly up front or monthly, and in which months do renewals fall? | Billing records, month by month, from the office person | 5.4 |
| Did repairs grow to fill the installation gap? | Repair and agreement totals from three years ago | 1 |
| What does one agreement visit cost to deliver? | Visits per agreement, typical time per visit including driving, and technician pay rate | 5.2 |
| How often do technicians offer an agreement on a repair visit? | A count of offers and sign-ups per technician over a season | 4 |

## Checks, in order of value

The first two decide whether the main problem is sales or margin; the third settles cash timing.

- [ ] **1. Estimate look-back.** For the last 12 months of quotes, mark each one member or new lead, won or lost, and days from call to quote. Even 30–40 quotes would show the pattern.
- [ ] **2. Invoices then and now.** Compare 2–3 common repairs and an agreement renewal from about three years ago with today, and do the same for supplier costs on the same parts.
- [ ] **3. Billing records with the office person.** Find out how agreements are paid (yearly or monthly) and how many renew each month.
- [ ] **4. Technician notes, going forward.** At each tune-up, record any new system a member had installed by someone else.

If most lost quotes are new leads, the fix is about competing for strangers. If many are members, the fix is inside the agreement program: spotting ageing systems early and quoting before a chain is asked.

## Context: typical maintenance-agreement pricing in the US

These are general national ranges from public web sources, mostly cost guides and HVAC software or marketing firms, not an independent survey. Local labor rates shift them. They say nothing about whether $275 covers this company's own visit costs; check 2 does that.

| Plan type | Typical range | Usually includes | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Basic, one system | $150–$300 a year (most priced $175–$250) | Two tune-ups a year, spring cooling and fall heating | [SmartService](https://www.smartservice.com/blog/how-much-hvac-service-agreements) |
| Comprehensive, one system | $300–$500 a year | Two visits plus priority service, repair discounts, small extras | [SmartService](https://www.smartservice.com/blog/how-much-hvac-service-agreements) |
| Basic (2026 vendor figures) | $159–$219 a year | 1 system, 2 tune-ups, 10% off repairs | [Plyrium](https://www.plyrium.com/academy/hvac/hvac-maintenance-agreements-pricing-2026) |
| Standard (2026 vendor figures) | $219–$329 a year | 1 system, 2 tune-ups, 20% off repairs, priority | [Plyrium](https://www.plyrium.com/academy/hvac/hvac-maintenance-agreements-pricing-2026) |
| Each additional system | roughly $75–$250 a year | Depends on whether each unit gets a full tune-up | [LatestCost](https://latestcost.com/hvac-maintenance-contract-cost-u-s-homes/) |

- **Structure:** tiered good-better-best plans are common. Most are billed yearly; many also offer monthly payment, for example $199–$329 a year or $19–$29 a month ([Pipeline](https://pipelineon.com/blog/hvac-maintenance-agreement/)). Some add a 12-month minimum and an early-cancellation fee.
- **Customer expectations:** homeowners expect at least two visits a year ([ACHR News](https://www.achrnews.com/articles/153922-residential-hvac-replacement-market-slowed-in-2025)).
- **Price increases:** one long-running contractor charges $250 a year per system and raises it about 5–10% every other year ([ACHR News](https://www.achrnews.com/articles/153922-homeowners-contractors-mutually-support-maintenance-agreements)).
- **Follow-on work:** software vendors commonly estimate about $2 of extra repair and replacement work per $1 of agreement value; this is a vendor estimate, not independent data ([Service Magazine](https://www.servicemag.org/guides/maintenance-agreements-recurring-revenue)).

## How this diagnosis thinks

It maps how the business makes money first: what is sold, to whom, and which income repeats. It then traces causes from that structure, weighing evidence over impressions. Facts, guesses and unknowns are kept separate, so a guess is never acted on as if it were proven.

## When to revisit

- When the results of check 1 or check 2 are in, even roughly.
- Before a decision you need to explain to others, such as a price change, a hire or a new way of selling agreements.
- When something you tried doesn't work and you want to know why.
- Ahead of the next summer peak, or if cash tightens again in a slow month.

PDN Skill v0.4.7
